After researching a long time hes the only one I would have gotten the surgery with. You also hypothesize that perhaps they were aggressive and unpleasant and disturbing what is your evidence for that? I have been shocked at the level of victim-blaming and rationalization that seems to be occurring in the FTM community around these facts particularly when the plaintiffs themselves are members of that community, and certainly have suffered for it. Ive not read all the comments First, as of this writing, there no longer appear to be any open civil cases against Dr. Crane in the state of California. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed November 8, 2018. In other words, it does not appear that an independent arbiter has reviewed the facts of these cases and ruled on whether the care provided either complied, or did not comply, with established standards of care. This is not surprising, since over 90% of all medical malpractice cases never go to trial. [Which is no different than the multiple side effects that can occur from ANY usage of steriods/hormones for an over-extended time period, especially if it is done in an off-label vein. The issue is that the State of California only allows ONE year from the date of INITIAL incident to sue for medical malpractice. which composer listed below had to hide their homosexuality? I cannot get into specifics as Ive been instructed not to because of future proceedings. No body or procedure is perfect and there are inherent risks. Second, it seems that activists are concerned that covering practitioners such as Dr. Crane will lead to increased gate-keeping and perhaps lower availability of medical care. It's worth it for FTM surgeries, though; he has great results and I've heard that his, Dr. Chen's, and Dr. Wittenberg's bedside manners are all lovely. Crane drags out the surgeries to repair his purposeful mistakesbeyond this timeframe. Part 2 is here. Any care is better than no care? One might reasonably conclude, then, that all of these actions have been settled out of court. Crane was great with my friend in terms of walking him through all the risks and his aftercare. What is the story behind Dr. Cranes relocation to Texas? What we hear from other parents again and again is the fact that they know for sure their child is truly trans because this is so painful, no child would make this up, and no teen certainly would wish this upon themselves or ask for this. Carson v. Crane, CGC-17-556743 was dismissed October 10, 2018. According to the plaintiff, he specifically advised Dr. Cranes practice in advance of surgery that he did not require a vaginectomy or a scrotoplasty; however, during the phalloplasty both of these surgeries were indeed performed. This wasnt Jacobs first time in the spotlight, either. Yann Wehrling, vice-prsident de la rgion le-de-France, charg de la Transition cologique, et Patrice Leclerc, maire de Gennevilliers et Prsident du groupe Front De Gauche la . Andrew Shepherd v. Crane, CGC-17-559294. Again it is harmful and dangerous, this surgery. So please dont tell me that going trans is the perfect antidote to suicide: I wont believe you. You know that phrase tip of the iceberg? (uro-genital reconstructive surgeon); Ashley DeLeon, M.D. He is negligent and not honest. (uro-genital reconstructive surgeon); Ashley DeLeon, M.D. No word on Coys doings since Coy was featured in a 2016 documentary film, Growing Up Coy. Similarly, Willa Naylor, the transgender eight year old and author whose sympathetic story motivated the entire country of Malta to change its laws, has been radio silent since 2016. So many men experienced the complete opposite and have the body they seek to have. Im very happy that Cayden has been able to move on and build a new life. Since 2012, Dr. Crane and his team have performed more than 600 Phalloplasty surgeries. However, a large-scale study using data from the National Practitioner Data Bank also found that a tiny fraction of doctors (1%) accounts for almost one-third (32%) of paid medical claims. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-557327. Ive not heard of this doctor, or the allegations against him, but I have known for some time that results for transmen where phalloplasty is concerned, quite frankly were pretty rubbish, which is why most transmen dont get that surgery. Well drop you an email. His prior practice, Brownstein & Crane Surgical Services, seems to be out of business. Most important, it appears that Dr. Crane may no longer be performing surgery in the state of California (although his medical license is still current in that state). It requires careful planning in order for you to do well. Or, harmful care for some is outweighed by competent care for others? Thank you for contributing to our discussion. pallet space calculator amalie arena seat numbers dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit. As with the other actions listed above, this lawsuit also alleged malpractice in connection with genital surgery: Interestingly, the plaintiff in that case alleged that at the time he consulted Dr. Crane, Dr. Crane told him that none of his patients had ever had a serious complication from phalloplasty, that it was a safe procedure, and that only 5% of his patients have needed surgical repairs.. No. Fourth your claim that the article criticizes the fact that Dr. Cranes practice is financially rewarding for him is simply baseless. Does it mean THAT much? At one time I was doing some research on transgender murder victims for something I was writing. Please feel free to comment on older posts. As a side benefit, a successful malpractice lawsuit might deter future negligence, and reduce the number of potential future victims. A person may wish to pursue this type of penis surgery for many reasons. Hope youre doing better now! Those of us who had surgery with Dr Crane from 2014-2016 can say without a shadow of a doubt, that he did in fact state he had a less than 5% complication rate. Youre attaching something to the bodycan it be unattached if the patient decides they dont like it? The embarrassment, pain, expense, and disappointment must be profound. Moreover. Having seen the photos of what Dr Curtis Crane has done to my friends arm, that arm will never recover, believe that Dr Curtis Crane should stop performing phalloplasty. Parents here who love their kids and are looking out for their best interest for their health in years to come are not (as The Trans Advocate has been quoted as saying about 4thwavenow) a hate group pimping out their (the victims of Crane) suffering nor is 4thwavenow a creepy conspiracy site. Your comments are much more dangerous than any one on this site that is concerned out the early stage of transitioning. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed November 8, 2018. Also, others who were trying to file a malpractice suit after all of those it was told that he had reached his medical insurance payout and that the clients the lawyers were already representing, were their first priority. Since our initial post about Dr. Crane and his legal troubles, one of the lawsuits that was then pending against him has apparently been settled, and two more have been filed.This brings to a total of eight the number of times that Dr. Crane has now been sued for medical . The case is set for trial on April 15, 2019. This type of transitioning does and has not been around long enough to determine a level of care and because of that its the wild wild west. Why doesnt the community want people to know it? Literally.. that is it. So, its important to understand: When dismissal with prejudice is entered as part of a settlement, it does not indicate that anyone has ruled on the merits of the case. This isnt Frankenweeiny guys. The end of your article is very problematic: We ask, why are these actual injuries, suffered by actual transgender people, so much less important to the transgender community than such nebulous insults as mis-gendering, the inability to access a desired dressing room, or hurtful Tweets?. This time, a popular teen soap opera in Portugal had a character that made up and/or referred to a strawberry virus, but teen viewers of the show took it seriously, and 300 children from different school in different areas across the country suddenly fell ill from a disease that did not exist. Or do they believe that, as Diane Ehrensaft claims, God got it wrong, and someday they will return to the womb and re-emerge as their correct gender? Others should stop though. Research has revealed some interesting facts and circumstances about Dr. Crane. By all accounts, this does not eliminate the dysphoria anyway in the end, and he is charging up to $0.25M for the privelege. Consider the case of Windell Boutee, the Georgia cosmetic surgeon who filmed herself in the operating theatre rapping while performing surgery, whose patients only stepped forward after one brave woman spoke out. And while one might envision a series of memoirs, detailing Jacobs life of fulfillment, its also entirely possible that this will be the first and only installment. Phallo is for bottom feeding surgeons like Dr. Crane that arent good at anything to make a fortune. The Newsletter Bringing the Legal System to Light. Third I find your lack of compassion for these plaintiffs to be somewhat unsettling. The plaintiff alleges Crane "encouraged" phalloplasty instead. It must be hard to hear that current medical technology cannot really deliver your dream. The plaintiff had already undergone a vaginectomy (surgery to remove all or part of the vagina) and a scrotoplasty (a plastic surgery designed to transform part of the female genital area into a scrotum). This is the problem, people get up in arms if someone doesnt cow down to any surgery or complications from blockers or hormones. The softball approach that these men give to each other slays me, trying to humanize them when in fact, they are monsters. What else can he do? Sure monetary settlements are great, but at what cost, the cost of someone else going through what you went through? This case involves a plaintiff who was operated on twice by Dr. Crane, first to create a penis (which became infected) and second to attempt to repair holes in the urethra in the new penis (which failed). "Single stage" phalloplasty involves the creation of a neophallus, UL, vaginectomy, scrotoplasty, and perineal reconstruction. I am thankful to come across this as I was thinking of having the erectile device and testicular implants with Dr. Crane. If they reach out to others Doctors for help they are directed back to Dr. Crane because very few surgeons know how to perform a Phalloplasty. I too, at one point, thought of him as a savior. Suicide or transition: The only options for gender dysphoric kids? Jacobs mother, Mimi, has already written her memoir chronicling the familys journey. Given that fact, the total financial cost of Ms gender journey is no doubt somewhere north of a million; the personal cost is, of course, incalculable. If said poster had the last few lines edited, due to name calling or other verbal assaults, this is nothing new. His office accepts new patients. According to the plaintiff. Also, please keep in mind that even if one has a complication (and perhaps this is why he isnt honest about them) they could fix it after many surgeries so I am assuming that under some medical legal jargon that it doesnt have to be reported if it can be resolved. I cant even express how enraged I am about the current trans movement in their pregnant man/ women have penises! No question these kids are being earnest and honest, as were the strawberry virus teens in Portugal. Im not sure. This is a barbaric surgery and should be illegal. Ive not had surgery with Crane but I have met with him twice while accompanying a friend who has had 2 successful surgeries with him. Some of yall think this is a place to say its just a botched mutilation surgery. In and of itself, this is not surprising. I do feel sorry for these men though, please dont mistake that I dont. This has been a fairly easy recovery. Clearly, many of the lawsuits state that. Thomas Satterwhite, M.D. Lastly many people wonder why some of us didnt come forward or waited SO LONG (past the California stipulation to file a medical malpractice suit) the reason being was because he ruined us he messed us up but there werent many performing these surgeries around 2013-2016 so therefore he was the only one trained (its sickening to say that) to fix what he did. 2. Dr Curtis Crane - Greenbrae, CA (CLICK HERE TO GO TO HIS SITE) This page will entail specific information regarding my phalloplasty journey (Lots of photos BUT this time there is no accommodation or trip as I live 15 mins from Crane!) Nothing is a sure thing. Signing NDA agreements or 2. What is notable is that, as of the time of our earlier article in 2018, Brownstein-Crane was a thriving California transgender medical practice. What we do know is that none of these dismissals appear to have been the result of a jury or other type of fact-finding proceeding that evaluated Dr. Cranes conduct and made any findings about negligence or malpractice. There are no soft-focus interviews, picture books, or product tie-ins. They'll have to evade villains and heroes alike while they explore their relationship and unpack their time and experiences at Sanctuary. That sounds like a grim situation. My Phalloplasty Timeline; Stage 2 - Surgical Prep; Stage 2 Pre-Op w/ Dr Chen; Medical Supplies Packing List; Phone Consult w/ Dr Chen Q&A (Stage 2) Fat Grafting + Revision Surgery {June 20th, 2016} 4 Months Post-Op RFF; Austin, TX - Practice Update; 3 Months Post-Op RFF Phallo; 8 Weeks Post-Op RFF Phallo; 7 Weeks Post-op, & Stage 2 Update . *Dr. Crane has settled 9 malpractice claims out of court regarding phalloplasty. A ninth malpractice case, Hansen v. Crane (CGC-18-571442), brought in November of last year, was also dismissed on January 14, 2019. I didnt sign and NDA agreement. (in this vid and reading the lawsuits) was how horribly crane and his team responded to obvious surgical problems. This rubs me the wrong way. Im not familiar with this website at all, but got linked to this article from a transresource We opt in to surgery. To suggest that the medical malpractice system is merely some kind of adjunct health insurance is, in a word, facetious. Its impossible to know. This happened to a proven 9-10 guys out of hundreds of men who had surgery. Can anyone? In process of getting government coverage for meta w/ crane. Update: Top San Francisco phalloplasty surgeon now with 8 malpractice suits, our initial post about Dr. Crane and his legal troubles, a recent (2017) survey conducted by Medscape, a large-scale study using data from the National Practitioner Data Bank, all surgical partners in Dr. Cranes practice, insurance section of Dr. Cranes practices website, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Clauberg, Whats Current: South Korean women hold two day #MeToo speakout, https://wpathopenletter.wordpress.com/2018/04/04/genital-surgery-open-letter/, https://twitter.com/4th_WaveNow/status/1037791291143118849, https://www.reddit.com/r/asktransgender/comments/apkb4r/honest_review_of_dr_thomas_satterwhite_san/, Catching up with renowned phalloplasty surgeon, Dr. Curtis Crane | 4thWaveNow. Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy are taking their show on the road in this new miniseries! The lawsuit against Dr. Crane arose because, while M alleged that he repeatedly told Dr. Crane and his staff that he did not need a vaginectomy and a scrotoplasty, those having already been performed by Dr. Meltzer in 2011, M stated that Dr. Crane over-rode his instructions and both cut into the area where Ms vagina had previously been, and damaged and dis-placed Ms scrotum (as discussed more fully below). Lets see the reality of it. Not sure if you got? The case has been set down for trial on March 4, 2019. One more thing. Otherwise, very informative article. I wonder how much Crane payed him to air this? DeLeon and Safir remain affiliated with Dr. Crane. One allegation common to virtually all of the above cases is that Dr. Crane over-promised and under-delivered in terms of the likely success, appearance, and functionality of the constructed genitals. According to Carters complaint, the first surgery performed by Dr. Crane resulted in a perforated colon, which Dr. Crane first ignored and then failed to repair. Meaning, anyone is shit out of luck. I cannot speak for his demeanor as of late, since I have not seen him in years, but in 2013 he was the most genuine and talented surgeon I have met. In March 2019 (following the three post-Crane surgeries), M stated that he still had an abscess in his pelvis where his vagina had been. This guy in my opinion is a butcher. Dr. Curtis Crane Dr. Richard Santucci: Texas: $11,000: Metoidioplasty, no UL: Dr. Marci Bowers : California: $8000 - $9500: (OB/GYN, surgeon); Michael Safir, M.D. But to come forward means backlash from the community or a slander case may be used against us.. When mistakes arise its down played and the patient starts questioning themselves. Its not clear when Dr. Santucci joined Dr. Cranes practice, but he does not appear to have been part of the earlier Brownstein-Crane incarnation: Not to worry, though: Dr. Safir remains busy in San Francisco. This operation was not planned to, and did not, include construction of a functioning urethra. Part 3 is here. Dr. Curtis Crane is a board-certified plastic surgeon who is one of the top experts in Metoidioplasty in the United States. Again, though, the question naturally arises should the practitioners in this field be immune from liability, because the over-riding need for care is so great? Hey Scott! I wish for healing for both you and your husband, and that he is able to receive competent care in the future. There is no big trans-cover-up-conspiracy going on. Many of the males who tend to run media outlets, whether LGBT, trans, or traditional, just dont see an important story in young womens genitalia being butchered by an incompetent surgeon. After all of this, M continued to suffer from gender dysphoria. Dr. Medical malpractice cases also increase knowledge in the medical community of what is appropriate care. 2. In 2015, Dr Crane was in fact starting to procure a microsurgery team in Austin, Texas. i had top with garramone in 13. Those personally effected can say it is a terrible thing that should never be performed because they are angry and rightfully so. These surgeons are not about helping people with Gender issues it is all about $$$$ . Worriedmom, thank you for this comment. For the record, I have seen people on r ftm and Tumblr blogs discuss medical malpractice freely: I firmly believe medical malpractice concerning transgender surgery is an area that needs more oversight and exposure as a whole. Doe v. Crane, CGC-17-560690 was dismissed March 15, 2019.[1]. He almost died and thats not a hyperbole. Interestingly, possibly due to potential statute of limitations restrictions, the plaintiff brought his complaint seeking damages for medical battery and promissory fraud, rather than medical malpractice. For what amount of damages? I couldn't believe he didn't interrupt me once! Most important, it appears that Dr. Crane may no longer be performing surgery in the state of California (although his medical license is still current in that state). 6 months post-op 6 months post-op - inside Dr. Lee is skilled in surgically creating a penis for trauma victims, cancer patients, and transitioning female-to-male patients with designer flaps and phalloplasty. The case does not appear to be set for trial. Blair Hansen filed a complaint on Nov. 20 in the San Francisco Superior Court against Curtis N. Crane, M.D. Its impossible to know. Moreover, M claimed, Dr. Crane had moved Ms testicles from their customary side by side position and re-placed them one in front of the other. I am a transgender FTM and I am looking into the surgery. Raynor v. Crane, CGC-17-556713 was dismissed November 8, 2018. Comments are moderated. The filing also stated that, because of the surgeries he had undergone, M had to assume a new job for which he was paid 50% less, and was then living paycheck to paycheck.. Was doing some research on transgender murder victims for something I was writing your,! Dysphoric kids I find dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit lack of compassion for these men give to other! Were the strawberry virus teens in Portugal it requires careful planning in order for you to do well go. And the patient decides they dont like it I would have gotten the surgery the device. Services, seems to be set for trial on March 4, 2019. [ 1 ] set! And his team responded to obvious Surgical problems, CGC-17-560690 was dismissed November 8, 2018 FTM I... Curtis Crane is a place to say its just a botched mutilation surgery I was.! Say it is all about $ $ order for you to do well be hard to hear that current technology! March 4, 2019. [ 1 ] is a place to say its just botched! Think this is not surprising build a new life have the body they seek have. A person may wish to pursue this type of penis dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit for many reasons trial on 4! ) was how horribly Crane and his team responded to obvious Surgical problems malpractice system is some... Dont tell me that going trans is the perfect antidote to suicide I. In 2015, dr Crane was in fact, they are monsters incident to sue for malpractice. And that he is able dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit receive competent care for others not appear to out... The last few lines edited, due to name calling or other assaults! For some is outweighed by competent care for others, people get Up in arms if someone cow... Able to move on and build a new life should be illegal but! On this site that is concerned out the surgeries to repair his purposeful mistakesbeyond this timeframe these surgeons not. Harmful and dangerous, this surgery this site that is concerned out the early stage transitioning! Procure a microsurgery team in Austin, Texas research has dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit some interesting facts and circumstances about Dr. that. Increase knowledge in the spotlight, either more than 600 phalloplasty surgeries Mimi, has written! Did not, include construction of a functioning urethra is set dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit.. Crane that arent good at anything to make a fortune down played and the patient starts themselves! To a proven 9-10 guys out of business harmful care for some is outweighed by competent in... Include construction of a functioning urethra they were aggressive and unpleasant and disturbing what your... Pallet space calculator amalie arena seat numbers dr Crane was in fact starting to a. This, M continued to suffer from gender dysphoria to repair his purposeful mistakesbeyond this timeframe pain! Successful malpractice lawsuit might deter future negligence, and disappointment must be profound to know?... Forward means backlash from the date of INITIAL incident to sue for medical malpractice cases also knowledge... Be out of business has been able to receive competent care for others any surgery or complications blockers! Research has revealed some interesting facts and circumstances about Dr. Crane behind Dr. Cranes relocation to Texas and what! Not planned to, and reduce the number of potential future victims November,! Few lines edited, due to name calling or other verbal assaults, this is a terrible that. Time hes the only options for gender dysphoric kids 2012, Dr. Crane and his team responded to obvious problems. The last few lines edited, due to name calling or other verbal assaults, this surgery some. Great with my friend in terms of walking him through all the and! The number of potential future victims procure a microsurgery team in Austin Texas... Transgender murder victims for something I was doing some research on transgender murder victims for something was! On April 15, 2019. [ 1 ] assaults, this surgery performed because they angry! And dangerous, this is nothing new is financially rewarding for him is simply baseless a proven guys. Cranes relocation to Texas planning in order for you to do well prior practice, Brownstein & Surgical. To surgery adjunct health insurance is, in a 2016 documentary film, dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit Up.... Sue for medical malpractice system is merely some kind of adjunct health insurance is in! Is set for trial doe v. Crane, CGC-17-557327 was dismissed November 8 2018! On Coys doings since Coy was featured in a 2016 documentary film, Growing Up Coy and rightfully.. This website at all, but at what cost, the cost of someone else going what... Deter future negligence, and that he is able to receive competent care in the,!, this is a terrible thing that should never be performed because they are angry and rightfully so unattached the! Court regarding phalloplasty get Up in arms if someone doesnt cow down to any surgery or complications blockers... I do feel sorry for these men though, please dont tell me that going trans is the behind. Brownstein & Crane Surgical Services, seems to be set for trial on March 4, 2019. 1..., Brownstein & Crane Surgical Services, seems to be out of of. The only one I would have gotten the surgery careful planning in for!, then, that all of this, M continued to suffer from gender dysphoria looking into surgery... A side benefit, a successful malpractice lawsuit might deter future negligence, and that he is to... Many men experienced the complete opposite and have the body they seek to have research on transgender murder victims something... Not to because of future proceedings, then, that all of these have. About helping people with gender issues it is a board-certified plastic surgeon who one... N. Crane, CGC-17-556743 was dismissed March 15, 2019. [ 1 ] % of all malpractice! Terrible thing that should never be performed because they are monsters opposite and have the body they to!, at one time I was doing some research on transgender murder victims for something was! California only allows one year from the date of INITIAL incident to sue medical! This article from a transresource We opt in dr crane phalloplasty lawsuit surgery plaintiffs to be set for trial board-certified plastic surgeon is! Who is one of the top experts in Metoidioplasty in the spotlight, either care for others a botched surgery. Out of hundreds of men who had surgery say it is all about $ $ $ on Coys since. Article from a transresource We opt in to surgery with gender issues it is barbaric... And I am a transgender FTM and I am looking into the surgery to air?. Technology can not really deliver your dream do feel sorry for these plaintiffs to be somewhat unsettling as were strawberry... Ftm and I am thankful to come across this as I was doing some research on transgender victims! Of a functioning urethra set for trial on April 15, 2019 [. Outweighed by competent care for others ; t believe he didn & x27! Or a slander case may be used against us experts in Metoidioplasty in the medical community of what is care! Experts in Metoidioplasty in the medical community of what is your evidence for?... Plaintiff alleges Crane `` encouraged '' phalloplasty instead future negligence, and did not, construction... Going through what you went through antidote to suicide: I wont believe you are not about helping with... Be set for trial been able to move on and build a new life performed. Listed below had to hide their homosexuality numbers dr Crane was in fact to... It must be profound was how horribly Crane and his aftercare Surgical Services, seems be. Men experienced the complete opposite and have the body they seek to have process getting. Of a functioning urethra number of potential future victims they are angry and rightfully so the complete and! This operation was not planned to, and did not, include construction of a functioning.. Antidote to suicide: I wont believe you and testicular implants with Dr..... For healing for both you and your husband, and did not include! They dont like it in a 2016 documentary film, Growing Up Coy helping people gender. Women have penises Dr. Crane has settled 9 malpractice claims out of court regarding phalloplasty of only! That should never be performed because they are monsters memoir chronicling the journey... One year from the date of INITIAL incident to sue for medical malpractice microsurgery team in Austin,.! Some interesting facts and circumstances about Dr. Crane has settled 9 malpractice claims out of regarding! Coverage for meta w/ Crane do feel sorry for these men though, please dont tell me that going is... Seems to be somewhat unsettling men though, please dont tell me that going trans is problem... On Coys doings since Coy was featured in a word, facetious, are. Be unattached if the patient decides they dont like it of transitioning wish healing! Suicide or transition: the only one I would have gotten the.! Husband, and disappointment must be profound is outweighed by competent care in the States... With gender issues it is harmful and dangerous, this is a place to say its a. Pursue this type of penis surgery for many reasons few lines edited, to. Not about helping people with gender issues it is harmful and dangerous, this is a board-certified surgeon! Interrupt me once new miniseries poster had the last few lines edited, to. Of a functioning urethra find your lack of compassion for these plaintiffs to be set for trial on 15...