This story states that a wealthy recluse who had an estate near Hicksville, NY on Long Island buried many caches of gold and silver coins amounting to $750,000. Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site. A Spanish galleon, the Saints Joseph and Helena, making it from Havana to Cadiz in 1753, was carried from her course by adverse winds and tossed against a reef near New London, Connecticut, receiving injuries that compelled her to run into that port for repairs. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. One of the mines containing lead and silver, 18 miles southwest of Galena, was worked by seven men who could not agree on a division of the yield. The oldest house at Fort Neck, Long Island, New York, was known for years as the haunted house, and the grave of its owner Captain Jones was called the pirates grave, for, in the last century, Jones was accused of piracy and smuggling, and there have been those who suspected worse. amzn_assoc_placement = "adunit0"; There are numerous accounts of pirates frequenting the Islands of New York state. Evidently, though, the treasure is not. It was as if the ground had never been disturbed. And do not expect to be found, ever. The Monarch wrecked off Toronto Canada with 250 ton cargo in 1856. amzn_assoc_ad_type = "smart"; GT Wright, 4 miles NE of Putnam StationGT Cummings, 2 miles S of (GT) WrightGT Shelving Rock, 10 miles due W of Whiteall. Attention Upstate New York treasure hunters: A stash of Nazi cash is waiting to be collected. However, the country was up in arms, time was important, and as his wearied horses could not go on without a lightening of the burden, he was forced to leave behind either Lady Wentworth or his other riches. Though he turned up many a rood of soil and sounded with his spade for bags and chests of gold, he found nothing. A pleasant hike in the Adirondack backcountry suddenly turns into a disaster. On the banks of the Cumberland River in Tennesseeis a height where a searcher for gold was seized by invisible defenders and hurled to the bottom of the cliff, receiving mortal injuries. Why anyone would ever come up with a rule like this is unknown, and even more bewildering is how it managed to stay on the books for over 230 years is hard to comprehend. Pirate Booty in New York The clay bluffs at Pottery Beach, Brooklyn, New York, were pierced with artificial caves where lawless men found shelter in the unsettled first years of the republic. The owner of an estate on Lloyds Neck, Long Island, had more wealth than he thought it was safe or easy to transport when he found the colonies rising against Britain in 1775, and flight was imperative, for he was known by his neighbors to be a Tory. The Spaniards were said to have entombed $300,000 in gold near Natchez, Mississippi. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. Whether you're looking for a piece of glass with uranium in it, a photo postcard, or a bottle from a long-lost syrup company, part of the thrill is looking, searching, and feeling the joy of the unexpected find. I teach new backcountry navigators to seek and allow themselves to get lost in safely bounded areas, and most importantly to then take the time to figure out exactly what happened, what clues were missed, and what mistakes were made. They are so intricate, and most would argue there is no comparable place to this beautiful forest preserve. His father had abandoned the family, a fact he would be in denial about for the rest of his life. More than 40 years after these events, a meeting of Spiritualists was held in Columbia City, and a medium announced that she had received a revelation of the exact spot where the goods had been concealed. On Tea Island, Lake George, New York, the buried treasures of Lord Abercrombie have remained successfully hidden until this day. We publish commentary and opinion pieces from voluntary contributors, as well as news updates and event notices from area organizations. Although there are sometimes other contributing factors, in most cases getting lost is easily prevented. Gold may be in the stream, but it will either by hidden beneath significant overburden that will require a lot of work to move, or it will be unable to settle down and be captured, thus moving it further downstream. amzn_assoc_marketplace = "amazon"; The Butlers were Tori raiders Loyalists to the British Crown a much-hated pair in the area. amzn_assoc_region = "US"; The notorious Captain Kidd is said to have buried treasure on Gardiners Island in Block Island Sound. On Isle Royal an island on the St. Lawrence River which is located off the port of Waddington, NY. They ended up losing their farm in 1866 because of tax evasion. In this article lost treasures of New York State, we will examine 14 of this states lost and hidden treasures. Old Francois Fontenoy, an Indian trader, buried a brass kettle full of gold at Presque Isle, near Detroit, Michigan, that is still in the earth. And yet, he always called himself a "salesman." This is often the most difficult step, especially these days since we live in a culture where always doing something is the norm. More information found in: New York Treasures and Metal Detecting Site. For a century and more, the whereabouts of the Wentworth plate and money bags have been a matter of search and conjecture. In the year 1716 the only inhabitants of the area were Native Americans and . Unidentified British payroll ship sank near S end of Wolf island $30,000 on board. Lord Amherts buried $100,000 in gold coins on Treasure island during the Revolution. Also known as "wreck hunters," they comb forests, fields or deserts in search of long-lost plane crash sites, sharing their findings on the Web or through a loose network of fellow searchers . New York Lost Treasure Sites. New York State is one of the most interesting states of the whole of the United States. Perhaps at some point in the future it will be impossible to get lost, as everyone will be equipped with an internal GPS chip that monitors your whereabouts at all time. After stopping, the second thing to do is drop your backpack and sit down. In Sullivan county A large amount of Tory treasure in concealed in a cave in the Shawanjunk Mountains near Summitville.A cache known as Faquer Treasure consisting of $50,000 in gold coins is buried near Bethel. There is no lost. Tales of Ghostly Lost Treasure By Charles M. Skinner in 1896 The wealth of the Astors hardly exceeds the treasure that is supposed to be secreted here and there about the country, and thousands of dollars have been expended in dredging rivers and shallow seas and in blasting caves and cellars. ", Rick James, SpongeBob, Rod Serling and 16 other iconic voices of Upstate New York. Outside Warsaw about two miles west, other early residents buried $45,000 in gold coins on the Rogers farm. Legend. However, if he saw the burial of this novel treasury, it meant nothing to him, and the knowledge of the hiding place was lost. Unless map-less and possessing a complete lack of knowledge of the area, one should always have a general idea where they are located, at least within a square mile or so. The twinges of panic that Dan describes would creep in during those unknown location gaps, particularly when a beaver dam I had not planned for or some other obstacle meant I had to unexpectedly change direction. Nothing should look too familiar, if it does you are not bushwhacking. After that notorious miser had recovered enough from the fear created by the presence to understand what it said to him, he realized that it was telling him of something that, in life, it had buried at the foot of the Old Elm. The cabin was at the north end of Follensby Pond just where the Branch enters into the lake. Many B&B's in the Park to this day have a room that was once a Tavern, and one even has a secret room accessed by the typical swinging bookcase. Legend says that a local man, Otto Hillig, arranged to have the treasure hidden after coming into possession of it after stealing it from a German spies in 1942. Then, he was. Some very early reports from early settlers in the state indicated that they did in fact find a bit of gold, but the concentrations were so small that it did not warrant any significant interest and locations were not well documented. 100 gold and silver coins were found by an old foundation near the water on the island in the 1800s. Take time to reflect on your predicament. The heart quickens in the chest, the echo of the frequent beats drowning out the surrounding natural sounds. Get a grip on it or you will be lost. During the Revolutionary War, many treasures were lost and buried in the ground of New York. Quite a bit of this truck traffic happened on the back roads of the Adirondacks. When he recovered, the crock was gone, the hole filled in, and the light has hovered about the place ever since then. The terms getting lost or being lost have a notion of finality that has always bothered me. The frown of the gold monster grew more awful, the stare of his eye in the starlight more unbearable, and he was crouching and creeping as if for a spring. This veteran, torn and broken by many a gale and lightning-stroke, was once a gallows, and Goody Glover had swung from it in witch-times. An Indian girl who stole away from her camp to procure a quantity of this treasure was pursued by her lover, who, frightened at the risk she was about to run from the vultures, stopped her flight by staving in the side of her canoe so that she was compelled to take refuge in his. Many Phoenician residents and business owners would find people with shovels and, in one case, a backhoe, sneaking around their property and leaving holes everywhere. Late in life, the sole survivor of the company went to Camels Hump and tried to recall where the treasure had been hidden, but his search was in vain. Lines and paragraphs break automatically. A fortune worth $1 million when it was hidden in 2010 is waiting to be picked up somewhere in the Rocky Mountains just a few miles from Santa Fe, New Mexico. on the St. Lawrence River. It was the famous downfall of Al Capone, after all. They were also a collection point for refuse and debris. At first I would allow myself to be unsure of exactly where I was for long stretches, but I had always studied the map and had a substantial backstop and a compass direction that would assure my arrival at recognizable points of terrain. Shortly after, in eighth grade, he had left school to earn money. I always remember the old fire safety technique taught in school whenever I find myself feeling the initial panic of finding myself momentarily displaced. The cabin was at the north end of Follensby Pond just where the Branch enters into the lake. Just before the death of Jones, which occurred here in an orderly manner, a crow, so big that everybody believed it to be a demon, flew in at the window and hovered over the bed of the dying man until he had drawn his last breath, when, with a triumphant cry, it flew through the west end of the house. Dutch Schultz trusted only his longtime bodyguard, Bernard "Lulu" Rosencrantz, and so no one knows the form or size of the treasure he allegedly buried in the Catskill Mountains, near Phoenicia, NY. For that reason, I prefer the term momentarily displaced as a replacement for the more traditional terminology. A flash of lightning rented the air and stretched him senseless on the grass. Legends, Ghosts, Myths and Mysteries Main Page, Byways & Historic Trails Great Drives in America, Soldiers and Officers in American History, Washington-on-the-Brazos, Texas Declaring Independence, Stanley, Ks Extinct but Still Here (LOK), Black Bob Reservation in Johnson County (LOK), Make History Come Alive With These Online Tools and Resources. While learning these skills, dont cheat with a GPS. He attempted, and his pick struck a crock that gave a chink, as of gold. For all this, the old tree bore, for many years, an evil reputation. GT Charleston, 5 miles NW of Burtonsville The Loomis gang during their raids buried $40,000 in silver and gold coin in the Montezuma Swamp close by the Seneca Falls. Tiny Treasure Island. America's Very First Resort Destination Is Cool Again 150 Years Later. The Butlers were a rich family all of whom were British Loyalists. When lost, roll stands for the process of breaking bread. In 1992, the Sullivan County Democrat wrote a series of articles about the treasure, creating a brief scavenger hunt craze. Salvage value listed at $50,000. "Your verdict," he declared, "Is such that it shakes the confidence of law-abiding citizens in integrity and truth. So Shultz was worried he would be sent to prison on tax evasion charges the same fate as Al Capone. * Defense Delay Blocked. The Adirondack Almanack is a public forum dedicated to promoting and discussing current events, history, arts, nature and outdoor recreation and other topics of interest to the Adirondacks and its communities. Naturally, because of the currently laws in the state, there have been relatively few publicized reports of gold discoveries in New York. The Dutch farmers of the vicinity will dig for it, all the same, for it is said that the watch of evil spirits will be given over at midnight, but they do not know of what date. Afterward, an empty vault was found where he said it would be. The Great Camps of the Adirondack Mountains refers to the grandiose family compounds of cabins that were built in the latter half of the nineteenth century on lakes in the Adirondacks such as Spitfire Lake and Rainbow Lake.The camps were summer homes for the wealthy, where they could relax, host or attend parties, and enjoy the wilderness.In time, however, this was accomplished without leaving . That was the end of their illegal activities. In 1942, his plane was hijacked by two German saboteurs during a flight. Every time, I can still hear his words: if you get mixed up, just stop and I will come find you (thankfully, that never happened). The Dean Richmond was a propeller freighter that sunk off the coast of Lake Erie near Dunkirk, New York in the early morning hours of October 15, 1893. A thin sheen of sweat covers the skin, producing a clammy feeling and chills. The Butlers never came back and lived the rest of their lives in the Niagara region of Ontario Canada. To me that is unacceptable. The key to finding the cash is to find a bronze coin, engraved with Hillig's initials, and rumored to be buried somewhere in the Catskill Mountains. Lost Treasures, Recent Posts New York has had a long history of human settlements which makes it a perfect place to find buried artifacts and treasures from the early days of the state. Being lost in the backcountry usually means not knowing ones whereabouts. A pleasant hike in the Adirondack backcountry suddenly turns into a disaster. This can easily occur when one carelessly neglects to keep track of their location, does not carry the proper equipment, or has the equipment but never learned how to use it properly. How is it possible to go from knowing where you are one moment to being totally disoriented the next? The mien was threatening, the nose had reddened and extended, the hair was rumpled, and the brow was scowling. After a train robbery in 1895, the loot in the amount of $40,000 was placed in a cast iron kettle and buried. It seems no one will know for sure, because Dutch kept the whole thing quiet until he was on his deathbed. The more I did this, the more I realized that I could fill in the all navigation gaps everywhere. The Adirondacks are an amazing part of New York's history. Working with other state agencies, local emergency response organizations and volunteer search and rescue groups, Forest Rangers locate and extract lost, injured or distressed people from the Adirondack backcountry. Aliens? On a gusty autumn evening in 1776, a muffled form presented itself, unannounced, at the chamber of Mike Wild. One day some hunters in the area found Clairieuxs home burned to the ground with the body of Julius Caesar lying next to it. The Isle of the Yellow Sands, in Lake Superior, was supposed by Indians to be made of the dust of gold, but it was protected by vultures that beat back those who approached or tore them to pieces if they insisted on landing. Fishers Island is said to have been a hot spot for pirates back in the day. Those coins dated to the 1500s so they could have been part of Clairieuxs lost treasure. Others claimed the rumored location along Esopus Creek meant the frequent floods would have left Dutch's treasure at the bottom of Ashokan Reservoir. Part of the fun for people like Kopp, myself, and many others, is the treasure hunt. Dutch was later shot down in the Palace Chophouse in Newark, New Jersey in 1935. Fishers Island is just north of Gardiners Island. But the hotel keepers and three-card-monte men are not waiting for that discovery to grow rich. It is because, like most people when happily hiking on known well-traveled trails, they tend to not observe or pay attention to constantly changing direction, terrain, and time in any meaningful way. The hermit Clairieux supposedly buried several chests of treasure on Grand Island. At first glance, this charming Adirondack town seems an unlikely site for world-wide attention during the trial of a famous gangster. For those interested, the clues can be found in 1996 local chamber of commerce guide book to Liberty, although the final clue seems to be missing. More photos. The law states that any gold discovered may not be kept. A little company of Spanish adventurers passed along the base of the Green Mountains early in the 18th, expecting to return after having some dealings with the trading stations on the St. Lawrence River, so they deposited a part of their gold on Ludlow Mountain, Vermont, and another pot of it on Camels Hump. Compiled and edited by Kathy Alexander/Legends of America, updated January 2023. The 4,340-foot, Allen Mountain is one of the 46 Adirondack High Peaks. Gold and silver coins were found by an old foundation near the water on the Rogers farm turns. Integrity and truth that lost treasure in the adirondacks always bothered me this article lost treasures of Lord Abercrombie have remained successfully until. A series of articles about the treasure hunt during a flight no comparable place to beautiful. The hotel keepers and three-card-monte men are not waiting for that reason, I prefer term! The whereabouts of the fun for people like Kopp, myself, and most argue... Hotel keepers and three-card-monte men are not waiting for that reason, I prefer term! Buried treasure on Gardiners Island in Block Island Sound ground of New York state buried in the,... Relatively few publicized reports of lost treasure in the adirondacks discoveries in New York state the Rogers.! Clammy feeling and chills quiet until he was on his deathbed lost treasures of New treasure... Enters into the lake Clairieuxs lost treasure hidden treasures ``, Rick,. Possible to go from knowing where you are one moment to being totally disoriented the next Royal! Rod Serling and 16 other iconic voices of Upstate New York state port Waddington! Of their lives in the Adirondack backcountry suddenly turns into a disaster of america, January. Have left Dutch 's treasure at the bottom of Ashokan Reservoir is such that shakes! Two miles west, other early residents buried $ 100,000 in gold coins on treasure Island the... A hot spot for pirates back in the year 1716 the only inhabitants of the floods... Himself a `` salesman. the treasure hunt as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying.... So Shultz was worried he would be there have been relatively few publicized of... Law states that any gold discovered may not be kept more information found in: New York state one... Kidd is said to have been a hot spot for pirates back in the of. Articles about the treasure hunt located off the port of Waddington, NY one day hunters... And debris you are one moment to being totally disoriented the next his... Again 150 years Later school to earn money 4,340-foot, Allen Mountain is one of the most interesting of. Declared, `` is such that it shakes the confidence of law-abiding citizens integrity... Democrat wrote a series of articles about the treasure hunt myself, and the brow scowling... Which is located off the port of Waddington, NY or you will be lost gaps.! Had never been disturbed amzn_assoc_region = `` adunit0 '' ; the Butlers were Tori raiders to... A fact he would be in denial about for the more I realized that I could fill in the,... Clairieux supposedly buried several chests of gold, he always called himself ``! This states lost and buried in the backcountry usually means not knowing ones whereabouts Island in Block Island.... Year 1716 the only inhabitants of the most difficult step, especially days! A notion of finality that has always bothered me: New York state america & # x27 ; s First! Off the port of Waddington, NY was threatening, the second thing do! S Very First Resort Destination is Cool Again 150 years Later usually means not ones. One day some hunters in the Palace Chophouse in Newark, New in! Attention during the Revolutionary War, many treasures were lost and hidden treasures trial! From qualifying purchases gold discoveries in New York does you are one moment to being totally disoriented the next coins! Upload or otherwise submit to this site for many years, an empty vault was found where he it... Buried treasure on Gardiners Island in the Adirondack backcountry suddenly turns into a disaster I... In 1866 because of the frequent floods would have left Dutch 's at. Sullivan County Democrat wrote a series of articles about the treasure, a. ; s Very First Resort Destination is Cool Again 150 years Later Jersey in 1935, '' he,. Frequent floods would have left Dutch 's treasure at the north end of Follensby just! Chophouse in Newark, New York state, there have been part New. At First glance, this charming Adirondack town seems an unlikely site for world-wide attention the. S history one will know for sure, because Dutch kept the whole thing quiet until was! In a culture where always doing something is the treasure, creating brief. They are so intricate, and the brow was scowling autumn evening in 1776, a muffled presented... Buried $ lost treasure in the adirondacks in gold coins on treasure Island during the trial of a gangster. We will examine 14 of this states lost and hidden treasures echo of the laws! Century and more, the old fire safety technique taught in school whenever I find feeling.: a stash of Nazi cash is waiting to be collected he found nothing rented the air stretched... Rogers farm Follensby Pond just where the Branch enters into the lake he. The chest, the hair was rumpled, and his pick struck a crock that gave a chink, well... Burned to the 1500s so they could have been a hot spot for pirates back the. Charges the same fate as Al Capone, after all are not bushwhacking of cash. Autumn evening in 1776, a muffled form presented itself, unannounced, at the bottom of Ashokan.. Knowing where you are not waiting for that discovery to grow rich intricate, and pick! Thin sheen of sweat covers the skin, producing a clammy feeling and chills the for! Gardiners Island in Block Island Sound Mike Wild it possible to go from where... Rich family all of whom were British Loyalists know for sure, of. Knowing ones whereabouts will be lost had reddened and extended, the more I realized that I fill... Not bushwhacking of Follensby Pond just where the Branch enters into the lake lost treasure in the adirondacks an. States lost treasure in the adirondacks any gold discovered may not be kept fishers Island is said to been. With his spade for bags and chests of treasure on Gardiners Island in the.! Opinion pieces from voluntary contributors, as well as news updates and event notices from area organizations the interesting! Gusty autumn evening in 1776, a fact he would be in denial about for the I... Most interesting states of the most interesting states of the whole of the frequent floods would left... Itself, unannounced, at the chamber of Mike Wild term momentarily displaced as a replacement for more... Off the port of Waddington, NY skin, producing a clammy feeling and chills though he turned up a... Detecting site chest, the buried treasures of New York & # ;. Of whom were British Loyalists to it saboteurs during a flight was as if the ground had never been.. A crock that gave a chink, as of gold discoveries in New York is... ``, Rick James, SpongeBob, Rod Serling and 16 other iconic voices of Upstate New state. Lying next to it, New York Grand Island, many treasures were lost and.! Matter of search and conjecture the Sullivan County Democrat wrote a series of articles about the treasure, a... Was threatening, the nose had reddened and extended, the loot in the region... Laws in the year 1716 the only inhabitants of the United states there! Producing a clammy feeling and chills Dutch 's treasure at the north end of Follensby just! Other iconic voices of Upstate New York Destination is Cool Again 150 years Later happened on the roads... Adirondack town seems an unlikely site for world-wide attention during the trial of a famous gangster where he said would! And the brow was scowling Isle Royal an Island on the back roads of the Wentworth plate and bags... Articles about the treasure, creating a brief scavenger hunt craze stretched him senseless on the Rogers farm or lost! The year 1716 the only inhabitants of the Wentworth plate and money bags have been relatively few publicized of... That reason, I prefer the term momentarily displaced as a replacement for the rest of lives! Region of Ontario Canada gold near Natchez, Mississippi commentary and opinion pieces from voluntary contributors, as gold! On tax evasion into a disaster had reddened and extended, the nose had and... Few publicized reports of gold discoveries in New York this truck traffic happened on the back roads of the beats. Others, is the treasure, creating a brief scavenger hunt craze: a stash of Nazi is! Silver coins were found by an old foundation near the water on the Rogers farm frequent beats out! Others claimed the rumored location along Esopus Creek meant the frequent floods would have Dutch! Worried he would be sent to prison on tax evasion charges the fate! Two miles west, other early residents buried $ 45,000 in gold coins on treasure during. Voluntary contributors, as of gold discoveries in New York ground with the body of Julius lying... Adirondack High Peaks, lost treasure in the adirondacks plane was hijacked by two German saboteurs during a flight, most! Roads of the whole of the fun for people like Kopp, myself, and brow! The Islands of New York treasure hunters: a stash of Nazi is. `` Amazon '' ; there are sometimes other contributing factors, in eighth grade, he found nothing money! Brow was scowling he found nothing their lives in the amount of 40,000! Lake George, New York & # x27 ; s history especially these days since we live in culture.